If you and your partner have decided that you don’t want more children or don’t want to have children at all, you may be considering permanent contraception, also known as sterilization. But once you’ve decided that one of you should be sterilized, you’ll need to decide who will have the surgical procedure, prompting the great debate of vasectomy vs tubal ligation.
Here’s what’s involved in each procedure, including the pros and cons of each, so you and your partner can make an informed decision.
Never Miss a Beat!
Subscribe to Our HealthBeat Newsletter!
Thank you for subscribing!
You are already subscribed.
Sorry, an error occurred. Please try again later.
Get Healthy Tips Sent to Your Phone!
What Is a Vasectomy?
Vasectomies are usually performed under local anesthesia. During the procedure, a surgeon cuts the vas deferens, the tube that carries sperm from your testicles to your penis; this makes it so that sperm are no longer able to exit your body. After cutting the vas deferens, the surgeon will either burn or tie off the ends.
During a conventional vasectomy, a surgeon makes two small cuts in each side of the scrotum to access the vas deferens. At the end of the procedure, the cuts are stitched closed. The newer, no-scalpel vasectomy involves the surgeon clamping the vas deferens from the outside after identifying it by feel, and then puncturing the scrotum for access to cut and tie the vas deferens. This type of vasectomy doesn’t require stitches and often has a shorter recovery time.
Regardless of the vasectomy method, you’ll probably need a few days to recover. Your doctor will likely recommend that you limit strenuous physical activity and ice the area to reduce swelling and pain. Follow-up is necessary to confirm there are no sperm in your ejaculate fluid.
Having a vasectomy should not affect your sex drive or your ability to have sex. If you have the procedure, seminal fluid will still be produced and will release during ejaculation; the only difference is that the fluid won’t contain sperm.
Vasectomy reversal is possible, but much more complicated; in a reversal procedure, the surgeon reconnects the vas deferens to allow sperm and seminal fluid to mix again.
What Is Tubal Ligation?
Tubal ligation cuts or blocks the fallopian tubes, which carry a woman’s eggs from the ovaries to the uterus. The operative procedure is often performed with a small camera and light called a laparoscope.
First, the surgeon makes small incisions in the abdomen. They may inflate the area with gas for a better view. Then, they’ll insert the laparoscope and instruments to block the fallopian tubes, which are either tied off, clamped, or burned. The incisions are stitched up at the end. Tubal ligation usually involves general anesthesia, though some surgeons use local or spinal anesthesia.
After the surgical procedure, the woman will spend a few hours in the recovery room, but she may be sent home the same day. She may have some discomfort from the gas and will need to rest at home for several days. She may also need to return to have her stitches removed.
Like a vasectomy, tubal ligation should not affect a woman’s sex drive. It also should not affect her period. Tubal ligation is sometimes successfully reversed.
The Pros and Cons of a Vasectomy vs Tubal Ligation
Which is better — a vasectomy or tubal ligation? While both are generally safe, tubal ligation is more complicated than a vasectomy. General or spinal anesthesia are sometimes used for tubal ligation, while a vasectomy only involves local anesthesia. Also, the tubal ligation surgery occurs in the abdomen, where there are more organs and blood vessels exposed than in a vasectomy, which only involves the scrotum.
It’s important to discuss the benefits and potential risks of each procedure with your doctor, and your partner, before making a decision.
UPMC, Vasectomy https://www.upmc.com/services/urology/conditions/vasectomy
UPMC, Vasectomy Reversal https://www.upmc.com/services/urology/conditions/vasectomy#vasectomyreversal
UPMC, Tubal Ligation https://www.upmc.com/health-library/article?hwid=abq4875
About Men’s Health Center
The UPMC Men’s Health Center evaluates and treats conditions affecting men’s sexual and reproductive health. With years of clinical experience in male sexual medicine and surgery, our team has treated a wide variety of conditions and performed thousands of surgeries. We are dedicated to providing patients the highest level of quality care. Our providers understand the intimate nature of male sexual difficulties, and we will work to help you restore your normal level of sexual function in a comfortable, educational, and discreet environment.